Deathcore/Metalcore/Hardcore >> Whats your opinion about Deathcore music ?
Share to Facebook Share to Myspace Share to Twitter Stumble It Email This More...

Post reply
   
InfinityZero
Monday 08 November 2010 - 02:36:55


citation :
Enigmatick says :
What difference does it make if they were influenced by thrash bands or not when there's Zero thrash in their sound? BFMV should not be in any way associated with Thrash Metal ever.

 
That is true.
Bullet for My Valentine is... once again... a write-off band. I remember back when I listened to Atreyu and then started listening to B4MV and found that a lot of Atreyu's stuff is used in B4MV songs. Anyway, why are we still on the topic of what genre B4MV belongs to? They're metalcore.
 
Or, if you prefer, "100% Metalcore and 0% thrash metal".

Enigmatick
Monday 08 November 2010 - 02:51:22

citation :
InfinityZero says :

 
Or, if you prefer, "100% Metalcore and 0% thrash metal".


There's ONE percentage I can agree with.


miniradman
Monday 08 November 2010 - 08:04:05

citation :
Enigmatick says :


citation :
InfinityZero says :



citation :
miniradman says : 
I'm not saying they are Thrash. I'm saying that they are Heavily Thrash influenced

 
That may be, but I think I read somewhere that about 70-80% metal bands today are (in some way) inspired by Metallica, who is a Thrash Metal band. So yeah, I can believe that Bullet For My Valentine is thrash influenced.


What difference does it make if they were influenced by thrash bands or not when there's Zero thrash in their sound? BFMV should not be in any way associated with Thrash Metal ever.

Besides, I'm sure TONS of metal bands are influenced by Metallica, they're a gateway band that got many, many people into metal, but that doesn't make all of those bands thrash influenced. Not by a long shot. Anything after ...and Justice For All by Metallica isn't really pure thrash anyways.

Also, I'm curious how you come up with these percentages. 20% thrash, 80% Metalcore, 15% grindcore...how exactly do you find these out? Are you listening to every single riff on each album and then objectively deciding whether that riff could be considered thrash or metalcore?

That's the only possible answer I could come up with. Either that or you're talking out of your ass.
EDIT: I was addressing miniradman in that last paragraph, not InfinityZero's "70-80% of bands are influenced by Metallica" shpiel.

 
Settle Down bala 0

miniradman
Monday 08 November 2010 - 08:14:07
I think that Metalcore is too diverse to make a judgement.0

Enigmatick
Monday 08 November 2010 - 21:47:06

citation :
miniradman says : I think that Metalcore is too diverse to make a judgement.0


That's a cop-out if I ever SAW one.


ChelseaGrin
Monday 08 November 2010 - 21:54:10
bla

Enigmatick
Tuesday 09 November 2010 - 01:51:30

citation :
ChelseaGrin says : bla


Profound.


miniradman
Tuesday 09 November 2010 - 10:56:43

citation :
Enigmatick says :

citation :
miniradman says : I think that Metalcore is too diverse to make a judgement.0


That's a cop-out if I ever SAW one.

 
Cop-out? But Metalcore is diverse?
 
you have thrashy ones. Trivium, Bullet For My Valentine, Atreyu
you have heavier ones. Parkway Drive, For Today, Never See Tomorrow
and you have Nu metaly ones. Demon Hunter (old), Sonic Synidicate.
 
See very different.

InfinityZero
Tuesday 09 November 2010 - 13:31:40

citation :
miniradman says :

citation :
Enigmatick says :


citation :
miniradman says : I think that Metalcore is too diverse to make a judgement.0


That's a cop-out if I ever SAW one.

 
Cop-out? But Metalcore is diverse?
 
you have thrashy ones. Trivium, Bullet For My Valentine, Atreyu
you have heavier ones. Parkway Drive, For Today, Never See Tomorrow
and you have Nu metaly ones. Demon Hunter (old), Sonic Synidicate.
 
See very different.

 
No man, 'cop-out' Means you're taking the easy way out.

Enigmatick
Wednesday 10 November 2010 - 01:39:48


citation :
miniradman says :
 
Cop-out? But Metalcore is diverse?
 
you have thrashy ones. Trivium, Bullet For My Valentine, Atreyu


thrashy???


holy fuck, you're making my nuts rupture here, man!

Also, to reiterate what InfinityZero said, that wasn't what I was getting at at all.

Post reply