Discussions about Music >> Does Flawless Equal Perfect?
Share to Facebook Share to Myspace Share to Twitter Stumble It Email This More...

 
Friday 23 September 2011 - 02:55:03
Hey guys, what do you think? Beacause an album is flawless, does it mean its perfect? Because there are many albums which I consider flawless in the sense that there are no off beats, the production is top quality and the music is non-repetitve. But I consider those to be 17-18/20 albums. A 20/20 (perfect) album for me would have to be able to revolutionize or bring something new to their respective genre. Or do you think not bringing something new to the metal scene is a Flaw in itself.

What do you think?


Friday 23 September 2011 - 03:07:04


citation :
miniradman says: A 20/20 (perfect) album for me would have to be able to revolutionize or bring something new to their respective genre.




So, by what you are saying, this is perfect? I like Unexpect, but they are Far from perfect.

Flawless Execution = perfect album
Something new = possibly good, but when it is good, it's amazing.

Now, if both of those are parts are present, then it is Beyond perfect.

Consider the following:


Friday 23 September 2011 - 04:25:17
Unexpect do bring something new I guess, but I don't think they'll start a revolution .


citation :
Now, if both of those are parts are present, then it is Beyond perfect.

Thats the only time that I would ever give a 20/20 score or those are the only albums I would consider perfect


Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:10:11
isn't Perfection, and Equality a form of perception when it comes to music.. so there for what i may think is a perfect album, may be utter shit to others...
Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:12:21

citation :
blackhawk308 says : isn't Perfection, and Equality a form of perception when it comes to music.. so there for what i may think is a perfect album, may be utter shit to others...

Like how someone sees a girl as being the hottest thing on Earth while someone else might see her as being a fat, ugly and stupid?


Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:14:53
Bingo! lol. like to me... i think that Metallica's St. Anger album is great... others would generally disagree, to a great degree.
Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:17:08

citation :
blackhawk308 says : ... i think that Metallica's St. Anger album is great...

That's a first

I see your point though




Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:20:47
haha, i bet so. i just don't see why people Hate it so much, i respect them for doing what they want to do, instead of doing the same ole same ole to keep their fans happy... actually i love all their albums, well except Load, i just can't get into it... lol
Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:23:45


citation :
blackhawk308 says : i think that Metallica's St. Anger album is great




Friday 23 September 2011 - 05:28:44
I really can't explain it. It's just one of those things, the album has clicked with me. It's so emotionally provoking at points, some songs make me wanna fuck shit up, and some make me want to relax and smoke a cigar on my front porch and enjoy life... so best explanation... I'm a complicated as Hell person, that cannot be understood, even by myself.