I know that the vast majority of people just want to hear the music on Youtube, don't care if it's official or unofficial account. Very few of them knows that it is monetization (ads/sponsor), illegal, strike and this things on Youtube.
The official band has released studio/live/demo/rehersal song on Youtube/CD/DVD/Bandcamp/Spotify/etc. And soon after, several unofficial people have uploaded the exact song on their Youtube account. First, I thought that unofficial have 1) play the song (ex. Iron Maiden - Two Minutes to Midnight) on his own unofficial and illegal account, and 2) also monetization on 1000 subscribers so would earn money from it. So that means:
- unofficial account is happy for he was earning money
- random user who playing the music is happy, they don't care whether if it's the unofficial has earnt or official has earnt money
- band and label was annoying, for the unofficial was stealing and rip them off for the bands songs. Very few band or labels has to report it and strike
Maybe I have I misunderstood it. Example, first user has three email for copyright strike, and then it was eventually taken down from the band or label.
- unofficial account is irritating for band/label was earning money, he earnt no money
- random user who playing the music is happy, they don't care whether if it's the unofficial has earnt or official has earnt money
- band and label was happy for earning money, no matter if it was the official or unofficial
Official with the studio version:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9qbRHY1l0vc
copy of the official:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xpCQE5jP538
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2IfM6HM2rRs
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=18dQDOQ_F5E
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rV31FmIyGOc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hfeZVlp8slc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2NRbycO0O_k
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rMLbokrWNSI
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7k2AvVtVNI
1) How can he have legal on his Youtube on example Two Minutes to Midnight?
studio.youtube.com -> Settings -> Upload defaults -> Advanced settings -> License
a) Standard YouTube License?, or
b) Creative Commons - Attribution?, or
c) none of these, somewhere else?
2) What is the point of adding yet another unofficial Two Minutes to Midnight?
3) Unoffical had filmed the concert and posted it on Youtube. How can he still have legal account?
- unofficial account is irritating for band/label was earning money, he earnt no money
- random user who playing the music is happy, they don't care whether if it's the unofficial has earnt or official has earnt money
- band and label was happy for earning money, no matter if it was the official or unofficial
4) Unoffical account has no monetization on official band, and it doesn't matter if it has less than 1000 subscribers or more than 1000 subscribers. But he can still have a strike, correct? How can he still have legal account?
5) Unoffical account has only 00:30 seconds preview from official band (ex. Two Minutes is 06:09). Can he still have a strike? How can he still have legal account?
